Compare

TruckerDB alternatives: trucking insurance lead tools compared

Four tools sell trucking insurance leads from FMCSA filings for under $250 a month. Here's what each one says it does, side by side, and where each is ahead.

BRBMC Radar

5 min read

Side by side

Every product here reads the same public FMCSA files. The differences are in which signals they pull out, how they handle the gaps since the May 2026 Motus cutover, and what they cost.

Lead tools

Feature by feature

BMC Radar compared with TruckerDB, XDate Alert, New Trucking Companies
BMC Radar$49/mo, or $39 billed yearlyTruckerDB$49 or $99/mo
Leads
CancellationsLiability filings that just endedYesNot stated
Replacements and reinstatements split outSo a refiled policy doesn't read as a lapseYesNot stated
New authoritiesCarriers that need a first policyYesPartly1
Estimated X-dates60 days outPro plan2
Insurer switchesYesNot stated
Every state on the base planYesNot stated
Data
Published X-date accuracyA measured hit rate, not just 'estimated'54,200 filings5Not stated
Carriers missing from Motus open dataActive carriers FMCSA's daily files leave outYes7Not stated
Phone and emailYesYes
Workflow
CSV exportYesYes
Watch your own bookAlerts only for your clients' DOT numbersYesNot stated
Pipeline trackingContacted, quoted, wonNoNot stated
API or webhooksNoNot stated
Team seatsUp to 5, $119/moNot stated
Try before payingFree sample listFree sample account
See plans
  1. 1.TruckerDB lists new DOT registrants.
  2. 2.TruckerDB's Pro plan has renewals 30, 45 or 60 days out, labelled as predictions.
  3. 3.New Trucking Companies shows switches for carriers on your watch lists.
  4. 4.New Trucking Companies' $39 plan covers one state; nationwide is $129.
  5. 5.Our backtest: 58 to 65% within a week of the anniversary once a policy is past about 11 months.
  6. 6.XDate Alert publishes a backtest figure of 56% in the anniversary week.
  7. 7.From FMCSA's May 14, 2026 records, checked each morning against the census.
  8. 8.New Trucking Companies runs on the daily Motus files and shows when each event first appeared.
  9. 9.XDate Alert lists owner and phone; email isn't stated.
  10. 10.New Trucking Companies lists webhooks and Google Sheets; its JSON API is on the $249 Team plan.
From each product's public pages, checked November 4, 2026. 'Not stated' means we couldn't find it there, not that the product lacks it. Prices are monthly.

Where BMC Radar is different

  • The carriers Motus leaves out. FMCSA's daily Motus open data carries about a third of active carriers. We add the rest from FMCSA's May 14, 2026 records, kept only where the daily census still shows the authority active, and label them as estimated.
  • Cancellations checked against the whole docket. Each cancellation is checked against every other liability filing on the carrier's docket, so reinstatements and same-day replacements don't show up as lapses.
  • X-dates with a measured hit rate. We checked the anniversary estimate on 54,200 filings and show each policy's age, so you can tell a strong X-date from a weak one. Here's the backtest.

Where the others are ahead

  • XDate Alert has a built-in pipeline (contacted, quoted, won) and 10 seats for $79 a month.
  • New Trucking Companies has webhooks and Google Sheets, a JSON API on its $249 Team plan, and a 7-day trial.
  • TruckerDB gives a free sample account and pushes to a CRM on its Pro plan.

Questions

What is the best TruckerDB alternative?

It depends on the lead you work. BMC Radar is built around cancellations with no replacement yet, measured X-dates and the carriers FMCSA's Motus open data leaves out, for every state from $39 a month. XDate Alert adds a pipeline and 10 seats for $79. New Trucking Companies has an API and webhooks on its $249 Team plan.

Are X-dates from these tools exact?

No. FMCSA doesn't publish policy end dates, so every tool estimates the X-date, usually from the anniversary of the current liability filing. On 54,200 filings we measured, 58 to 65% of policies past their first year ended within a week of the anniversary.

Why does Motus coverage matter?

Since FMCSA moved licensing and insurance to Motus in May 2026, its daily open data carries only about a third of active carriers. A tool that reads only those files misses most renewals. On the November 4, 2026 run, about three in four of BMC Radar's renewal leads came from FMCSA's May 14 records.

BR

BMC Radar

Built by EMBE LABS LLC from FMCSA public data

Share this post

Keep reading